Skip to main content

Don't Give Us Fish! On the DMO's Response to Why Nigeria is Borrowing From China - #ChinaAfrica

The Nigerian Debt Management Office's response to concerns about Nigeria borrowing from China is the equivalent of one saying "God forbid" to the possibility of a car crash... and then proceeding to drive without a seat-belt
Saying the possibility of a failure to default does not exist is an extremely naive statement. It's just like saying the possibility of a recession did not exist because Nigeria was the largest economy in AfricaAlso the Zambia example is not yet ancient history. 
The question the DMO needs to answer is, what happens if there is a default?
The reason concessional loans exist is because they come with certain conditions that favour the lender directly or indirectly. They either influence your policy-making or tie you into agreements that significantly hamper the potential for independent economic growth in future with severe penalties in case of a default. 
The question I ask is where did China, Singapore or South Korea borrow from to become economic giants they are today? Perhaps African leaders should borrow lessons from these countries rather than money.
A book I recommend for any one interested in public service is Bad Samaritans by Ha-Joon Chang. The book highlights how South Korea actively ignored the influence of the World Bank and IMF in shaping its economic policies and future. African leaders should borrow a leaf and apply the same caution to accepting aid from the East.
The other question the DMO needs to answer is, what are the conditions to which the loans are tied?
The gradual takeover of Zambian public assets by China due to unpaid debt should serve as a cautionary example for the Nigerian government. Particularly when we constantly borrow to fund a bloated civil service, an overpaid House of Assembly and extreme government excesses. While our leaders can only see 4 years into the future, China has actively been charting its future for the past 65 years with clear plans for the next quarter of a decade. If China truly wants to be benevolent, it should teach Africa to fish instead of building fishponds all over the continent. 


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Uzoma Okere: A Case Among Many

This is a note that I published on facebook two years ago after an unfortunate incident in Victoria Island, Lagos where a young lady was physically assaulted in broad daylight by military men. A few days ago, after being piqued at the sight of a military man violating the recently passed state law prohibiting the use of motorbikes on the Third Mainland bridge in Lagos, I decided to publish this article to a wider audience. ...................................................................................................................................................... November 5th, 2008, I felt elated. For apparently no reason. I mentioned this to my boss and he said it was just hope. Hope that if an african can rule God's own country, then there's no limit for me. I replied that there was no way that directly transcends to me here, in Nigeria. Obama being the US president doesn't stop some cretin in a uniform under the guise of being a police "officer" h...
The movie, Long Shot looks like a load of laughs. The movie features Charlize Theron as an American presidential candidate who runs into a childhood friend and they both proceed to get involved in the most unlikely shenanigans. What's more interesting though is the way Hollywood has started to sow the seed for a female president. I had a discussion with a colleague about how Hollywood influences the psyche, the culture and the laws in America (and the rest of the world by extension) only to watch this movie trailer a few days later. The idea of a black American president was seeded over a long time. The earliest I remember was in the 1997 Bruce Willis movie The Fifth Element. The concept seemed ludicrous at the time but it kept coming back to Hollywood. 24 was another good example. A more realistic one. It showed what a black First Family would look like. And the American people bought into it. That is one of the roles of art in a society. Record our history, shape our psyche,...